On the eastern tip of Long Island, beyond the glitz of the Hamptons, lies lovely laid-back Montauk. A charming beachside fishing town with great surf and a fun, chic feel, Montauk has long been popular with New Yorkers looking to escape the city. Home to everything from low-key B&Bs to luxury beach clubs, accommodation options in Montauk cater to a wide range of tastes and budgets. Our selection of the best places to stay in Montauk embodies the lovely retro-cool appeal of this trendy surf haven, promising the ideal weekend away for foodies and outdoorsy travellers.

One of Montauk’s greatest attractions is undoubtedly the beach. Gorgeous Ditch Plains Beach is a huge hit with surfers, though it’s also perfect for afternoons of lazy sunbathing and seaside strolls. Lake Montauk, on the other hand, is home to New York State’s largest sporting fishing fleet, whilst Deep Hollow Ranch — the oldest working ranch in the country — offers horse riding treks across its 3000 acres of beach and countryside. Explore Hither Hills State Park for hiking, cycling, fishing and swimming in the summer, or try Montauk State Point Park for wintry seal-watching walks. Whether you’re keen on kayaking, sailing or living like a cowboy out on the ranch, Montauk has plenty to keep lovers of the great outdoors entertained.

Visit the town’s famed 200-year-old lighthouse for spectacular views, and experience a snapshot of local history at Second House, a cottage built for East Hampton shepherds in the 18th century. The oldest surviving structure in town, Second House also boasts the intriguing Montauk Indian Museum, showcasing artefacts from the area’s original Native American inhabitants. Regular film nights, talks and events offer a valuable insight into Montauk’s past.

Don’t miss strolling through town, where there are hip cafes, delectable seafood eateries and fun bars to sample and savour. Thirst-quenchers from the Montauk Brewing Company are a real treat — especially on summer evenings abuzz with live music. Whilst most of the best places to stay in Montauk are close to the beach, one of our favourite retro summer camp-style hideaways is tucked inland, and wonderful for chilled campfire evenings in the garden. Montauk is a hugely popular destination, so book well in advance to avoid missing out!

The Best Places to Stay in Montauk

For couples

• The Montauk Beach House is a trendy boutique spot in downtown Montauk, just a block from the beach. Rooms are cool and chic, whilst the pool bar and DJ nights draw a lively weekend crowd. A hip hotel for grown-ups looking to unwind with great cocktails and freshly grilled food by the fire.
• Sunrise Guest House is a charming beachfront B&B, a mile from downtown Montauk. With just four spacious guestrooms and superb sea views, this is a lovely pick for an intimate beach break as a couple. Delicious homemade breakfasts are a highlight.

For Families

• Hero Beach Club is a laid-back beach resort with elegant rooms showcasing white-on-white decor, Balinese handicrafts and lovely private balconies — some of which have ocean views. Whilst this can be a cool grown-up spot, larger suites, a welcoming pool and kids’ movie nights make it a great pick for a family beach getaway.
• Haven Montauk offers a trendy take on the classic American motel, with 27 airy rooms and suites right on the harbour. Only steps from the beach, the property offers flexible room options for couples and families. Take a cooling dip in the pool, and round up a BBQ feast with s'mores. Very relaxed.

For bohemian living

• Ruschmeyer's is a rustic haven offering a retro summer-camp experience beside Montauk's Fort Pond. The Magic Garden sports hammocks, tree swings and fire pits, whilst there are activities and adventures galore. Chic, minimalist rooms brim with boho charm, and the nightlife is electric.

For Barefoot Luxury

• Gurney's Montauk is a luxurious Hamptons spa hotel set on a striking stretch of private beach. Pick this place for the swish, contemporary interiors, six delectable dining options, top-notch surfing, fun kids' club and a soothing spa. Indulgent rooms, suites and cottages promise something for everyone. Absolute bliss.

For a holiday house or apartment

• If you'd prefer a self-catering option, we suggest that you visit our online partner Booking.com.

Travel information

• The Long Island Railroad (LIRR) offers regular trains from New York City to Montauk. Check the schedule for direct trains, as some make a stop in Jamaica. Seasonal ferries run between Block Island, London and Martha's Vineyard, while Montauk also has its own airport for chartered planes and private jets.
• If you would like to hire a car, we suggest that you contact our online partner Rentalcars.
• For warm days, visit Montauk between June and August when temperatures peak at around 26°C and there’s plenty to do outdoors. This is, however, the busiest time of year — time your trip for September or October for tranquility without the crowds. Montauk is also a charming winter destination, with cosy hotels, cross-country skiing and seal spotting.

Still not sure?

• Expand your search to include all the best places to stay in East Hampton.
• Alternatively, see our pick of the best places to stay on Long Island.
• Or contact one of our friendly Gurus for advice.

Weather

Monthly Weather in Montauk