The Hotel Guru
The 18 Best Hotels in the Finger Lakes

The 18 Best Hotels in the Finger Lakes

The Finger Lakes region is one of New York State's most dramatic and scenic areas. 11 long and narrow glacial lakes are what gives the area its name. Featuring gorges, waterfalls, thick woods, and rolling hills — this is a playground for the adventurous and outdoorsy. Accommodation in the area varies depending on the reason for your visit. From romantic rural hideaways to chic boutiques; our hotel experts have picked the best hotels in Finger Lakes to make choosing your next stay a quick and simple decision.

For a cosy traditional stay

Morgan Samuels Inn is a charming 17th century stone mansion. The six sumptuous bedrooms come complete with cosy fireplaces and antique furniture. Mouthwatering gourmet meals are served in the elegant dining areas, both al fresco and indoors. Prepare to be pampered!
The William Henry Miller Inn is a charming inn set in the heart of downtown Ithaca. Rooms are elegant and traditional with antique furnishings, local artworks and added luxuries such as whirlpool tubs. An authentic stay well positioned for accessing local attractions.
Quinta Rosa Estate is a rustic Queen Anne Victorian home set on a charming country estate. Each room has its own unique style but the feel throughout is traditional with a clean contemporary spin. With endless outdoor pursuits in the surrounding area, this is the perfect choice for a rural weekend getaway.
For that quintessentially rustic feel pick the Chalet of Canandaigua, an elegant and intimate inn set in the hills of Canandaigua. Rooms are designed like a traditional log cabin with added luxuries including working fireplaces, soaking tubs, and enormous beds. An idyllic rural hideaway.
The Bond 1835 is a historic farmhouse (built in 1835) set overlooking Skaneateles Lake. Light and beautiful rooms channel farmhouse chic with cream colour schemes, antique furnishings, hardwood floors, and tiled bathrooms with stand-alone tubs. A cosy choice for a rural hideaway.

For luxury

Geneva on the Lake Boutique Resort Hotel is a luxury lakeside resort situated on 10-acres overlooking Seneca Lake. Rooms are heavenly with beautifully handcrafted Stickley furniture, wood-burning fireplaces and spa baths. Indulge at the delicious farm-to-table restaurant, stroll the gardens, and take a dip in the pool. Rural perfection!

For the spa

Mirbeau Inn is a beautiful resort reminiscent of a French country estate just outside Skaneateles, featuring a world-class spa offering a sauna, steam room, and a wide selection of treatments. An indulgent rural hideaway ideal for a rejuvenating stay.

For a couple's escape

Argos Inn is set in an imposing old colonial mansion in Ithaca. This hotel combines modern style with old-world charm. Chic rooms feature polished wooden floors, warm hues and antiques. A grown-up property offering impeccable design and an alluring craft cocktail bar. The perfect base for a romantic getaway.
Inns of Aurora is a collection of 4 elegant inns offering a spectacular setting by Lake Cayuga. Each house has its own distinctive style with bold colours and an artsy play on traditional design. With its luxurious interiors, superlative wellness centre, fine-dining, and sophisticated activities like wine tasting — this property screams romantic getaway!
1795 Acorn Inn is an award-winning rural B&B with vast multi-terraced grounds. The rustic exterior opens onto well-appointed interiors; each country classic room has a different strength but all feature homely fireplaces. Enjoy the outdoor hot tub, hammocks, in-room massages and fireside lounge. An intimate woodland wonderland perfectly primed for romance.
The Inn at Gothic Eves boasts fabulous suites perfectly suited for a couples' break. Expect four-posters, in-room couples' massages, fireplaces, jetted tubs and showers with body sprays. Hammocks are strung up in the garden, ideal for whiling away the afternoons. A relaxing escape.

For families

The Grayhaven Motel is a charming laid-back motel set in 11 acres of woodland, home to local wildlife. The property comprises spacious rooms, suites and cottages with airy mid-century design (some have kitchenettes). The casual feel, well-priced accommodation, endless space, and well-equipped playground make this a great choice for families.

For great value

Burdett House is a quaint owner-managed converted Victorian home with just four rooms. Guestrooms have a homely traditional feel with original features and period-appropriate furniture. With rooms starting around the $100 mark, this is a charming and affordable rural getaway.

For the location

Magnolia Place B&B is a beautiful 1830s farmhouse with stunning Seneca Lake views. Lovely rooms offer a mix of contemporary comforts and period touches. With spacious grounds, a large wrap-around porch, and gourmet breakfasts - this is a wonderfully tranquil base to return to.
Inn at Taughannock Falls boasts an epic location overlooking Cayuga Lake and Taughannock Falls State Park. A Victorian Inn, the interiors remain traditional and stylish yet with added luxuries such as spa baths. Mornings begin enjoying the views with a cup of coffee from your private balcony. A charming base for an outdoorsy break.
The Lake House on Canandaigua is a modern luxe lakefront hotel offering a complete getaway package. Boutique interiors perfectly blend fresh minimalism with unique character and warmth. With a heated pool, library, cutting-edge dining and lake-front views, this property is hard to leave!
Moonshadow Bed and Breakfast is an intimate and homely lakeside property. This pretty rural cottage has surprisingly contemporary interiors, with decor inspired from around the world. Rooms feature lake-view balconies, tech touches and modern bathrooms. A fabulous laid-back hideaway.
2W Lake is an upscale boutique B&B set in a historic Victorian home on Skaneateles Lake. Elegant rooms boast wonderful views from expansive windows and homemade breakfasts are served on the porch. A tranquil and homely option to explore the lake area from.

Still not sure where to book?

Expand your search to include all our properties in New York State.
Alternatively, look at the best places to stay in Niagara Falls, Rochester, and Buffalo.
Or contact one of our friendly Gurus for advice.
- Morgan Samuels Venue Canandaigua (New York State) 7 rooms from £91
  
  See more photos
  
  Great walks  -  Not only does the property boast wonderful walking trails but the picturesque Finger Lakes Region is just a short car ride away.
  Birdwatching  -  Plenty of wildlife to be seen on this tree-covered rise, surrounded by 46 private acres.
  Romantic  -  Good for couples.
  Full of character
  
  A charming 19th century stone mansion, situated in the breathtaking Finger Lakes District. The seven sumptuous bedrooms come complete with cosy fireplaces and antique furniture. Mouth watering gourmet meals are served in the elegant dining areas, perfect for big family trips or weddings. See More
  
  Check Availability
- Mirbeau Inn Skaneateles (Saratoga Springs) 34 rooms from £183
  
  See more photos
  
  Hideaway  -  Retreat into the inn's secluded 12-acres of serene gardens - set against a back drop of dense spruce trees
  Sights nearby  -  Visit the village of Skaneateles, Cliff Park, Baltimore Woods Nature Centre, Skaneateles Boat Show
  Romantic  -  Good for couples.
  Back to Nature
  
  A beautiful, picturesque resort overlooking Manet-inspired pond and gardens. Reminiscent of a French Country Estate. Features a world class spa offering a sauna, steam room, treatments, private bar, and complimentary fitness classes. Escape into this magical, French inspired retreat. See More
  
  Check Availability
- Argos Inn Ithaca, NY (New York State) 13 rooms from £128
  
  See more photos
  
  Local exploring  -  A spoiling base to explore the state's natural bounties including vineyards, waterfalls and gorges
  Eco break  -  The environmentally-friendly Argos Inn has geothermal heating and is LEED certified
  Great walks  -  The city is surrounded by magnificent waterfalls and famous gorges for stunning days out hiking
  Lakeside  -  Cayuga Lake is approx 3km away
  Recommended by  -  Tablet
  
  Set in an imposing old colonial mansion, this hotel combines modern style with old-world charm. Chic rooms feature polished wooden floors, warm hues and antiques. A grown up property offering impeccable design and an alluring craft cocktail bar. The perfect base to explore Ithaca from. See More
  
  Check Availability
- Burdett House Burdett, New York State 4 rooms from £86
  
  See more photos
  
  Local exploring  -  Finger Lakes offers an impressive range of activities; from kayaking, boating and fishing to wine trails, museums & quaint towns
  Wine tasting  -  Seneca, Cayuga and Keuka wine trails are all in the area. There are also fantastic breweries to visit and beer trails
  Value chic  -  Fab rates mean that this makes for an affordable weekend away in a heavenly rural area
  Great walks  -  Spend the day hiking in Watkins Glen State Park with impressive gorge, slate stone staircases and 19 waterfalls and cascades
  
  Queen Anne Victorian home with quirky contemporary interiors. Lovingly converted by the owners, each room is home to eclectic furnishings and decor that feels fresh and fun in keeping with architectural features. Enjoy lovely leafy garden and country village setting with scenic rural surroundings. See More
  
  Check Availability
- Inn at Taughannock Falls Trumansburg, New York State 23 rooms from £94
  
  See more photos
  
  Views  -  The 13 acres of land overlooks the Cayuga Lake and Taughannock Falls State Park
  Restaurant  -  The restaurant offers classic American cuisine with a Mediterranean influence
  Back to Nature  -  Explore the Taughannock Falls State Park, right on the Inns doorstep
  Great walks  -  Adjacent to the tallest waterfall east of the Rocky Mountains, a perfect destination for a day's hike
  
  A Victorian inn overlooking the Cayuga Lake and Taughannock Falls State Park. Rooms are traditional and stylish with royal blue hues, antique furnishings, private balconies, spa baths and breathtaking views. The restaurant serves hearty American fare. A characterful base for an outdoorsy holiday. See More
  
  Check Availability
- The Inns of Aurora Aurora, New York State 43 rooms from £133
  
  See more photos
  
  Romantic Break  -  Luxurious interiors, a superlative wellness centre, and sophisticated activities like wine tasting - it screams romantic getaway
  Wellbeing  -  Ayurvedic consultations, yoga classes, and Serenity Sessions are held in the wellness centre
  Wine tasting  -  Set in New York’s premier wine region, this makes a great option for an adult weekend-away
  Cooking classes  -  Signature demonstrations, tasting experiences and skills workshops are held in the property's demonstration kitchen
  
  A collection of 4 elegant inns offering a spectacular setting by Lake Cayuga. Each house has its own distinctive style with bold colours and an artsy play on traditional design. Complete with 2 restaurants, excellent wines, a cookery school & wellness centre - you'll want for nothing here. See More
  
  Check Availability
- The Lake House on Canandaigua Canandaigua (New York State) 125 rooms from £140
  
  See more photos
  
  Value chic  -  Top-class luxury amenities, aesthetics and facilities within an affordable price range. Get a lot more than you pay for
  Romantic Break  -  Idyllic setting to escape; reconnect with fireside cocktails, vibey dining, sexy suites and interesting activities
  Country Escape  -  Explore all Finger Lakes has to offer; lake views, walking trails, waterfalls, wild swimming and vineyard tours
  Restaurant  -  Rose Tavern serves rustic seasonal menu inspired by the region, enjoy views & outdoor dining. Sand Bar offers drinks and snacks
  
  Modern luxe lakefront hotel offering a complete getaway package. Boutique interiors perfectly blend fresh minimalism with unique character and warmth. A heated pool, library, cutting-edge dining and lake-front views make it hard to leave yet Finger Lakes area offers plenty to do. On-trend delight. See More
  
  Check Availability
- The Grayhaven Motel Ithaca, NY (New York State) 16 rooms from £144
  
  See more photos
  
  Total relaxation  -  Make the most of the property's acres with walking trails, outdoor firepits, picnic areas, lawn games, hammocks and birdwatching
  Back to Nature  -  Finger Lakes area offers countless state parks, waterfalls, lakes and forests. Enjoy fishing, hunting, skiing and wild swimming
  Artworks  -  There is an artists-in-residency program for writers, illustrators, media artists and calligraphers
  Business meetings  -  Book the property exclusively for a fun laid-back offside retreat for up to 50 guests
  
  Charming laid-back motel in rural Finger Lakes. Set on 11 acres of woodland, home to local wildlife, the property is made up of spacious rooms, suites and cottages with airy mid-century design and decor. Some have kitchenettes and dining options are in driving distance. Ideal for families or groups. See More
  
  Check Availability
- The Inn at Gothic Eves Ithaca, NY (New York State) 8 rooms from £226
  
  See more photos
  
  Local exploring  -  The Finger Lakes area is well known for its deep lakes, bountiful harvests, wine, ciders, beers, music scene and the arts
  Romantic Break  -  Book a room with a four-poster and indulge in the couples' massage that comes when booking the 'couples package'
  No restaurant  -  Breakfast is provided
  Sights nearby  -  Visit a variety of attractions including Watkins Glen, Cornell University, and Ithaca College
  
  A charming inn located in the heart of Fingers Lakes. Suites are elegant and spacious with custom tiled bathrooms, heated bathroom floors, fireplaces, jetted tubs and showers with body sprays. Hammocks are strung up in the garden and delicious, organic breakfasts are served. A relaxing stay. See More
  
  Check Availability
- 2W Lake Skaneateles (New York State) 2 rooms from £156
  
  See more photos
  
  Active Holiday  -  The Finger Lakes offers a host of water activies with boating, canoeing, kayaking, paddle boarding, or just simply swimming
  Local exploring  -  Stroll out the front door and find treasured art galleries, local bakeries and unique boutique shops
  Great walks  -  A must-visit are the Carpenter Falls and Charlie Major Nature Trails
  Lakeside
  
  An upscale boutique B&B set in a historic Victorian home on Skaneateles Lake. Elegant rooms are decorated in natural hues with hardwood floors and wonderful views from expansive windows. Homemade breakfasts are served on the porch. A tranquil and homely base to explore the lake area from. See More
  
  Check Availability
- The William Henry Miller Inn Ithaca, New York State 9 rooms from £152
  
  See more photos
  
  Active Holiday  -  The Black Diamond Trail runs 8.5 miles along the slopes of Cayuga Lake and is good for biking, hiking and cross country skiing
  Local exploring  -  The inn is the showpiece of downtown Ithaca, minutes away from the attractions
  No restaurant  -  Breakfast is provided
  Great walks  -  Walk the ten blocks to the breathtaking Ithaca Falls
  
  A charming inn, set in the heart of downtown Ithaca. Rooms are elegant and traditional with antique furnishings, local artworks and whirlpool tubs. Enjoy delicious breakfasts expect sweetbreads, hot entree dishes and fresh juices. An authentic stay well positioned for accessing local attractions. See More
  
  Check Availability
- The Bond 1835 Skaneateles (New York State) 5 rooms from £101
  
  See more photos
  
  Country Escape  -  A charming farmhouse set in mature gardens just moments from serene lakes, a tranquil rural hideaway
  Great walks  -  Discover Taughannock Falls on Cayuga
  Lakeside
  Views  -  Great views from hotel
  
  A historic farmhouse, built in 1835, set overlooking Skaneateles Lake. Light and beautiful rooms channel farmhouse chic with cream colour schemes, antique furnishings, hardwood floors, and tiled bathrooms with stand-alone tubs. Unwind in the mature gardens or enjoy water activities. A rural idyll. See More
  
  Check Availability
- Geneva on the Lake Boutique Resort Hotel Geneva, New York State 29 rooms from £211
  
  See more photos
  
  Local exploring  -  The inn is situated in the heart of Finger Lakes Region and offers the perfect starting point
  Restaurant  -  Lancellotti's features live music, farm fresh local foods, and wine and spirits of the Finger Lakes
  Swimming Pool  -  Take a dip in the picturesque 70-foot swimming pool
  Whirlpool Bathtub  -  A variety of suites and studios have Jacuzzi tubs
  
  A luxury lakeside resort situated on 10-acres overlooking Seneca Lake. Rooms are heavenly with beautifully handcrafted Stickley furniture, wood-burning fireplaces and spa baths. Indulge at the delicious farm-to-table restaurant. Stroll the gardens and take a dip in the pool. Rural perfection. See More
  
  Check Availability
- Magnolia Place B&B Hector, New York State 8 rooms from £162
  
  See more photos
  
  Local exploring  -  Take a balloon ride, go riding, sail on the lake, visit a winery or hike and bike in state parks, there's lots to do in the area
  Back to Nature  -  Finger Lakes Country offers pristine waters of Seneca Lake, impressive waterfalls, state parks and endless hiking trails
  Romantic Break  -  Romantic suites in the original farmhouse offer jetted spa tubs, fireplaces, love seats and access to sunset porches
  Great walks  -  Head to Watkins Glen State Park for hiking trails with impressive gorge, stream and waterfall views
  
  Rural 1830s farmhouse with Seneca Lake views converted into an elegant B&B. Lovely rooms offer contemporary comfort and finish with period touches, some feature charming four-poster beds and spa tubs. After gourmet breakfast head out to explore or relax on the wrap-around porch and large grounds. See More
  
  Check Availability
- Chalet of Canandaigua Canandaigua, New York State 3 rooms from £199
  
  See more photos
  
  Local exploring  -  The inn is perfectly located in the wooded hills of Canandaigua nearby to the wine, cheese and beer trails and mountains
  Great walks  -  Explore the trails of the New York State Finger Lakes Region
  Restrictions on children  -  Children over the age of 12 are welcome
  Traditional
  
  An elegant and intimate inn set in the hills of Canandaigua. Rustic chic rooms are spacious and stylish with walk-in showers, soaking tubs, king-sized beds, and fireplaces. Delicious three-course gourmet breakfasts are served on the porch overlooking the pond. An atmospheric rural escape. See More
  
  Check Availability
- Moonshadow Bed and Breakfast Hammondsport, New York State 4 rooms from £164
  
  See more photos
  
  Hideaway  -  Enviable lake-view location surrounded by mature trees feels wonderfully tucked away, yet close to all nearby attractions
  Local exploring  -  Whether you're into wine, fishing, hiking or simply exploring the countryside, Finger Lakes offers much to visitors
  Wine tasting  -  Located on the Keuka Lake Wine Trail; there are endless local wineries to explore and taste at
  Minimum Stay  -  Minimum stay varies between 2 and 3 nights during different times of the year
  
  Lakeside hideaway with an intimate homely feel. Pretty rural cottage has surprisingly contemporary interiors, with decor inspired from around the world. Rooms feature lake-view balconies, tech touches and modern bathrooms. Fab for laid-back stays with a games room, gardens and spacious common areas. See More
  
  Check Availability
- 1795 Acorn Inn Canandaigua (New York State) 5 rooms from £169
  
  See more photos
  
  Country Escape  -  Leafy surroundings, wildlife, large gardens and beautiful rural landscapes for miles make a stay here a breathe of fresh air
  Active Holiday  -  Outdoor enthusiasts will love the Finger Lakes area. Enjoy hiking, mountain biking, boating, fishing, swimming and canoeing
  Hideaway  -  Tucked away but with every little luxury you need for a relaxing weekend, this is a perfect little hideaway
  Sights nearby  -  It's possible to visit Niagra Falls as a day trip. While there, include Botanical Gardens and Butterfly Conservatory
  
  Award-winning rural B&B with vast multi-terraced grounds. Rustic exterior houses well-appointed interiors; each country classic room has a different strength but all feature homely fireplaces. Enjoy the outdoor hot tub, hammocks, in-room massages and fireside lounge. Intimate woodland wonderland. See More
  
  Check Availability
- Quinta Rosa Estate Newfield, New York State 5 rooms from £182
  
  See more photos
  
  Weddings  -  Well-suited to weddings with turn of the century barn, large grounds with babbling brook and exclusive-use option for main house
  Country Escape  -  Idyllic rural spot with undisturbed countryside spanning for miles all around. Perfect for peaceful weekend breaks
  Great walks  -  This is waterfall country. Head out hiking to Lucifer Falls, Enfield Falls and Lick Brook for the most scenic
  Sights nearby  -  It's a 15 min drive into Ithica. Visit Cornell Botanic Gardens, Farmer's Market and a range of museums
  
  Rustic Queen Anne Victorian home on a charming country estate. Each room has its own unique style; both French Country rooms boast romantic beds and spoiling tubs. Large deck overlooks the garden and spacious living areas are ideal for relaxing. Traditional barn is perfect for events. See More
  
  Check Availability