A picturesque island escape, Martha’s Vineyard is known for its lack of chain restaurants (it has zero), its grand swathes of sand, its green almost pastoral interior and, of course, for being the setting for Jaws. Our Gurus have quite a lot to choose from when refining their recommendations for the best places to stay on Martha’s Vineyard. There are several cosy New England Inns, charming converted colonial mansions and some really beautiful farmhouse hotels; all primed for that perfect back to nature escape.
You’ll find some of our recommendations for the best hotels on Martha’s Vineyard in gentrified Edgartown, which has some seriously impressive celebrity second homes, some incredible restaurants and a gorgeous bay. But there are also properties dotted across the island, from old-fashioned beach resort, Oak Bluffs, to pretty Tisbury which is also where you’ll find the ferry port to Cape Cod, which is about seven miles away.
There’s plenty to see and do here, but don’t think seeing just one or two lighthouses will tick that particular box, see all five if you can. Long Point Wildlife Refuge is wonderful for a walk, but the whole coastline really deserves exploring. There are also some well-considered vineyards, good fishing and great food.
During the warm summer months, the area is particularly popular so to be sure to bag one of the best places to stay in Martha's Vineyard, we recommend booking well in advance.
No spam. Only sweet updates about the latest hotel openings and the best places to stay.
Martha's Vineyard (Massachusetts)
21-room B&B with fantastic dockside location in Martha's Vineyard. Rooms and suites have been recently renovated and feel cosy yet modern. All open out onto a shared terrace, and there is large sundeck, hot tub and sauna to return to after a day exploring. Generous complimentary snacks are offered.
Martha's Vineyard (Massachusetts)
A charming clapboard mansion, overlooking the harbour on Martha's Vineyard. Rooms are cosy, understated and elegant with huge windows, hard wood floors and bright cheerful colours. The sit out terrace commands incredible views of the bay. Full of natural charm and 'that island feeling!'
Martha's Vineyard (Massachusetts)
This 1891 coastal hotel has over 100,000 cedar trees, an outdoor pool and views of Edgartown Harbour. Light comfortable rooms with modern bathrooms and vineyard views. The Lighthouse Grill focuses on fish and steak, whereas the North 41 is poolside. Head to Henry's Hotel Bar for cocktails and tapas.
Martha's Vineyard (Massachusetts)
Small farmhouse resort resting in manicured lawns with heated pool, and award winning restaurant whose menu incorporates fresh local ingredients. Rooms are classically done but with a very contemporary feel. Relax or explore the local area on one of the complimentary bikes. A stunning spot!
Martha's Vineyard (Massachusetts )
Iconic lighthouse design grafted onto a 19th-century Victorian home has created an eccentric but stylish B&B in a delightful seaside town. Nine rooms and a penthouse are done up in bright, calming, seaside colours, with stylishly designed fabrics. Great hosts and beaches close by. Delightful!
Martha's Vineyard (Massachusetts)
An old Methodist summer camp, turned funky upscale boutique hotel in Oak Bluffs. The interiors have been carefully selected to invoke feelings of nostalgia for camp days of your childhood, while maintaining a level of elegance and style that places you right back in the present day. Characterful.
Martha's Vineyard
A chic owner managed B&B in Martha's Vineyard with seven elegantly styled rooms, all offering en suites, parquet floors and light natural tones. The breakfast is utterly delicious and can be served in bed or in the sunny dinning room. With extensive gardens and the village and beach nearby.
Martha's Vineyard (Massachusetts)
Barefoot bliss on the New England shore. A collection of sea-facing rooms and historic bungalows that have been in operation since the 1950s. Decor keeps things simple to play to the scenic outdoors; it's classic coastal Massachusetts with pale pastel hues, clapboard walls & white wooden furniture.
Martha's Vineyard (Massachusetts)
Inn and apartments on a quiet tree-lined avenue with a lovely garden and pool. Made up of classic Cape Cod-style rooms and spacious self-catered suites, decor blends nautical theme with antique furnishings and fun touches. Bike rental is included. A good option for groups of friends or long stays.
Martha's Vineyard (Massachusetts)
Historic B&B located in the heart of Edgerton, Martha's Vineyard. 8 rooms are situated in the Victorian-era 1892 Captain's House, with 14 in a new adjacent block. There is a buzzy restaurant loved by locals, a garden with iconic Adirondack chairs and walking access to everything you will want to do.
Martha's Vineyard
Classic clap-board boutique hotel with surprisingly trendy interiors. Rooms have individual decor ranging from mismatched metallic & monochome glam to airy New England white-wash. There's colourful outfoor furniture, garden & fire-pit. Contemporary cute, perfect for weekends away with a good friend.
Martha's Vineyard (Massachusetts)
19th Century home turned boutique hotel with manicured garden, sit out porch and classic interiors. Rooms house big beds, bright bathrooms and delicious breakfast in the dining room. In-house spa, gym and sauna are for all to relax in wine country. Check out the The Hob Knob 27' Boston Whaler boat.
Martha's Vineyard (Massachusetts)
A charming Victorian era mansion turned upscale B&B by the famed Lark group. The vibrant and thoughtfully curated interiors are a welcome breath of fresh air in Edgartown. Serving a hearty breakfast, as well as evening snacks in the courtyard, guests are made to feel welcome and looked after.
Martha's Vineyard (Massachusetts)
Family-friendly beachside resort in Katama, Martha's Vineyard. This generous property has a fantastic friendly team, heaps of complimentary activities and amenities for all ages and boasts a spa, 2 pools, lawn and outdoor dining with sea-views. There are 54 rooms, studios, suites and private villas.
Martha's Vineyard (Massachusetts)
19th-century colonial-style captain's home transformed into an elegant B&B. Rooms are the definition of old-world charm with four-poster beds, fireplaces, wooden floors, period furnishings and a fresh nautical colour-scheme. Enjoy downtime in the library, tea room & gardens. Classic coastal charm.
Martha's Vineyard (Massachusetts)
Owner-run inn situated in a charming 1923 cedar-shingle building in a quaint part of Martha's Vineyard. 15 rooms are split between the main building, cottages and vacation homes; the latter two are self-catering. There are plenty of walkable dining options and the property offers snacks and drinks.
Martha's Vineyard (27 South Summer Street)
British style 1864 house turned romantic boutique, with manicured gardens and antiques. The perfect place to unplug and unwind. Large, classical rooms with four poster beds, fireplaces and fine linens. Delicious American cuisine with French and Italian influences. The perfect romantic break.
Martha's Vineyard (Massachusetts)
Cool, contemporary boutique luxe meets New England charm. A former whaling captain's home, this white clapboard faced inn feels fresh and cosy at the same time. Rooms boast sophisticated muted grey palettes, whitewashed woods & warming woollen throws. Grown-up romance for a weekend away by the sea.
Martha's Vineyard (Massachusetts)
A historic tavern transformed into a modern retreat in Edgartown's heart. Chic, mid-century style rooms meet beach-luxe vibes with a dash of opulence too. Savour local cuisine, relax by the revamped pool, and explore vibrant Martha's Vineyard. An enchanting blend of history and contemporary luxury.
