Best B&Bs on Martha’s Vineyard

Martha’s Vineyard is a picturesque island escape, probably best known for “Jaws”, its sandy vistas, and for its complete lack of chain restaurants. With that in mind you can probably imagine that there’s a lot of competition for the best B&Bs on Martha’s Vineyard, because there’s a lot of independent, really personal accommodation, and a lot of it is excellent! Our Gurus worked hard comparing ocean views, cosy linens and gourmet breakfasts to being you this list of the best B&Bs on Martha’s Vineyard.

For a Beach Break

The Christopher’s vibrant, confident interiors are a charming contrast to its staid-but-elegant, Victorian exterior. This classic Edgartown mansion has been completely reimagined into a bright, 15 room B&B. Each of the rooms is unique, featuring original art and a range of colour schemes. A hearty breakfast and evening snacks are served in the courtyard, and there’s a friendly sitting room too. They have lots of spare beach towels if you’ve forgotten to bring one.

For Island Chic

The Edgartown Inn is a cool, contemporary choice, with boutique hotel-style interiors in a sophisticated grey palette. Converted from a the white-clapboard home of a whaling captain, the B&B now has 12 rooms, a light and airy breakfast room, a sitting room and a gorgeous porch. And all about a ten minute walk from Lighthouse Beach.
The Richard is a hybrid boutique hotel/B&B, converted from a classic clapboard mansion. The original large windows set the tone for this light, bright pick, and simple, contemporary decor makes each of the 16 rooms feel fresh and spacious — the decor is different in each room, and some are more traditionally New England than others. The garden has colourful outcrop furniture and a fire pit.

For Romantics

The Ashley Inn has been carefully converted from a 19th century Captain’s home, into a ten room B&B, while retaining the old-world charm and many of the original features. Expect four-poster beds, wooden floors, fireplaces and period details, against a traditional, nautical backdrop. Guests are also welcome in the library, the tea room and the gardens. Bliss.

For Families

The Dockside Inn is a grand and elegant 21 room B&B in a fantastic spot — beside the docks. The decor is cosily contemporary, and all the rooms have large windows and open out onto a shared terrace with water views. There’s also a shared hot tub and sauna, and a generous range of complimentary snacks, including ice cream and home-made cookies. There’s lots of paraphernalia for families, and you’re just 200 metres from Oak Bluffs Town Beach.

For Couples

The Nobnocket Boutique Inn is a chic, owner-managed B&B. Its seven ensuite rooms and suites are elegantly decorated, featuring wooden floors and lots of white, and there’s a charming sitting room with an open fire to relax in too. Breakfast is served in the sunny dining room, or in your room. A stylish pick close to the village and the beach.
Converted from a Captan’s house, built in 1892, The Sydney is a 22 room B&B in the heart of Edgartown. Eight rooms are in the original house, and 14 in an adjacent, newer block. The decor is cheerful, and, unusual for a B&B, there’s a lively little restaurant. This is a great base, within walking distance of the beach and lots of other attractions.

For an Island Escape

The Beach Plum Inn is a collection of sea-facing bungalows that have been hosting guests since the 1950s, and offer peace, comfort and charm in a pastel colour scheme. The decor is classic Massachusetts: clapboard walls and wood furniture. You can self-cater, but breakfast is served in a charming little dining room, and they offer pop-up dinners by local chefs in season.

For Great Value

Mansion House is a charming New England style clapboard mansion overlooking the harbour — especially from its higher floors! There are ample porches and balconies to make the most of the sun and sea views, and some of the 48 rooms and suites have private balconies. The decor is cosy and homely, with huge windows and hardwood floors. A really affordable way to capture that island holiday feeling.

Still not sure where to book?

You could browse all the best places to stay on Martha’s Vineyard
Or consider our recommendations for the best family hotels on Martha’s Vineyard
Alternatively, you could contact one of our friendly Gurus for personalised advice.

9 Best B&Bs on Martha’s Vineyard

Mansion House

Martha's Vineyard (Massachusetts)

A charming clapboard mansion, overlooking the harbour on Martha's Vineyard. Rooms are cosy, understated and elegant with huge windows, hard wood floors and bright cheerful colours. The sit out terrace commands incredible views of the bay. Full of natural charm and 'that island feeling!'

Kayaking - Explore the rich wildlife on Island Spirit Kayaks; or the calm North shore waters, sandy public beaches and inland harbors.
Sailing - With Atlantic Yachting you can charter a private boat, take a sailing lesson or just sit back a relax.
Restaurant - Copper Wok is just next door
Swimming Pool - Indoor year round pool.

from CA$179 for 1 room, 1 night including taxes & fees

Nobnocket Boutique Inn

Martha's Vineyard

A chic owner managed B&B in Martha's Vineyard with seven elegantly styled rooms, all offering en suites, parquet floors and light natural tones. The breakfast is utterly delicious and can be served in bed or in the sunny dinning room. With extensive gardens and the village and beach nearby.

Value chic - As well as luxury accommodation you can expect complimentary bikes, beach towels and much more included in the price
Romantic Break - For a romantic break book the Grand room, complete with fireplace, freestanding tub and plush linens
Great walks - Martha's Vineyard is crammed with great walking and hiking trails for all abilities
Birdwatching - The woods are filled with a variety of birds, make sure to pack your binoculars

from CA$238 for 1 room, 1 night including taxes & fees

The Christopher

Martha's Vineyard (Massachusetts)

A charming Victorian era mansion turned upscale B&B by the famed Lark group. The vibrant and thoughtfully curated interiors are a welcome breath of fresh air in Edgartown. Serving a hearty breakfast, as well as evening snacks in the courtyard, guests are made to feel welcome and looked after.

Beach Life - A beautifully laid out beach-chic B&B offering J Crew beach bags, towels and chairs on loan, as well as hot local tips
Sights nearby - The hotel provides an ipad filled with info on local attractions such as local restaurants, spas, bars and bike trails
Great walks - There are plenty of hiking and walking trails on the island, ask at the front desk for details
Barefoot Luxury

from CA$383 for 1 room, 1 night including taxes & fees

Check availability on Expedia

Dockside Inn

Martha's Vineyard (Massachusetts)

21-room B&B with fantastic dockside location in Martha's Vineyard. Rooms and suites have been recently renovated and feel cosy yet modern. All open out onto a shared terrace, and there is large sundeck, hot tub and sauna to return to after a day exploring. Generous complimentary snacks are offered.

Beach Life - Famous Oak Bluffs Town Beach is just 200m away. Beach chairs, umbrellas, coolers, toys and towels are all offered complimentary
Families - Unlike many boutique B&Bs in the area, children are welcome and there are games and toys available for them to use
Local exploring - This well-located B&B is close to everything that matters; ferry port, beaches, restaurants, shops and activities
Sights nearby - Take a guided historical tour of the island, including a visit to of all six towns and a stop at cliffs of Aquinnah

from CA$171 for 1 room, 1 night including taxes & fees

Beach Plum Inn

Martha's Vineyard (Massachusetts)

Barefoot bliss on the New England shore. A collection of sea-facing rooms and historic bungalows that have been in operation since the 1950s. Decor keeps things simple to play to the scenic outdoors; it's classic coastal Massachusetts with pale pastel hues, clapboard walls & white wooden furniture.

Back to Nature - There is something about the endless ocean, sandy beaches stretching for miles and wild landscapes that relaxes the soul here
Beach Life - Walk to the beach and stay all day. Menemsha beach is 200m from the property and there are many other nearby options
Total relaxation - The property describes itself as a respite from busy life; simply relax, swim, read, walk and enjoy the quiet life
Great walks - Take a walk through Menemsha, a small fishing village known as the filming location for Jaws, with its boutiques and cafes

from CA$248 for 1 room, 1 night including taxes & fees

The Sydney

Martha's Vineyard (Massachusetts)

Historic B&B located in the heart of Edgerton, Martha's Vineyard. 8 rooms are situated in the Victorian-era 1892 Captain's House, with 14 in a new adjacent block. There is a buzzy restaurant loved by locals, a garden with iconic Adirondack chairs and walking access to everything you will want to do.

Local exploring - A great location to engage with all that Martha's Vineyard has to offer; cultural, sporting, culinary and outdoor pursuits
Sights nearby - Stroll through the historic neighborhood of captain's homes to Edgartown Lighthouse. Climb to the top for magnificent views
Lively
Sailing

from CA$297 for 1 room, 1 night including taxes & fees

Check availability on Expedia

The Edgartown Inn

Martha's Vineyard (Massachusetts)

Cool, contemporary boutique luxe meets New England charm. A former whaling captain's home, this white clapboard faced inn feels fresh and cosy at the same time. Rooms boast sophisticated muted grey palettes, whitewashed woods & warming woollen throws. Grown-up romance for a weekend away by the sea.

Local exploring - As well as endless activities on the island, the location is walking distance from Edgartown's shops, galleries and restaurants
Beach Life - Lighthouse Beach is a 10 minute walk. Joseph Sylvia State Beach is great for swimming whereas South Beach has big waves
Sights nearby - First-timer's to Martha's Vineyard will love the island sightseeing tour which stops at Aquinnah Cliffs and Gay Head Lighthouse
Great walks - The property is just a block away from the water overlooking Chappaquiddick Point

from CA$499 for 1 room, 1 night including taxes & fees

The Richard

Martha's Vineyard

Classic clap-board boutique hotel with surprisingly trendy interiors. Rooms have individual decor ranging from mismatched metallic & monochome glam to airy New England white-wash. There's colourful outfoor furniture, garden & fire-pit. Contemporary cute, perfect for weekends away with a good friend.

Local exploring - The Main Street locations means Edgartown's galleries, shops & restaurants are on the doorstep, while the beach is a short walk
Great walks - Spend the day exploring the Polly Hill Arboretum. Take a picnic basket, tours the grounds and take in the botanical wonders
Sights nearby - A tour of the island will take you to gingerbread cottages of Oak Bluffs, Edgartown Lighthouse & the Jaws filming locations
Sailing - The property can organise a boat charter; for an unforgetable evening book in for the 4th July fireworks

from CA$349 for 1 room, 1 night including taxes & fees

Check availability on Expedia

Ashley Inn

Martha's Vineyard (Massachusetts)

19th-century colonial-style captain's home transformed into an elegant B&B. Rooms are the definition of old-world charm with four-poster beds, fireplaces, wooden floors, period furnishings and a fresh nautical colour-scheme. Enjoy downtime in the library, tea room & gardens. Classic coastal charm.

Local exploring - Beaches, nature reserves, museums, lighthouses, shops and farmer's markets are a walk, cycle or short drive away
Great walks - Walk, fish and picnic over 211 acres in Menemsha Hills Reservation. Enjoy beach, views, and stunning flora and fauna
Sailing - Yuo can't visit MV without some time on the water; head out fishing, kayaking, paddle-boarding or sailing
Sights nearby - The movie Jaws was filmed on Martha's Vineyard. Take a tour to visit all of the film's famous locations

from CA$442 for 1 room, 1 night including taxes & fees

Check availability on Expedia

9 Best B&Bs on Martha’s Vineyard

For a Beach Break

For Island Chic

For Romantics

For Families

For Couples

For an Island Escape

For Great Value

Still not sure where to book?

9 Best B&Bs on Martha’s Vineyard

Sign up to our weekly newsletter