The most northern of the Hamptons’ charming seaside towns, Sag Harbor sits just across from idyllic Shelter Island. Popular with families and couples eager to unwind by the seaside, the area offers a wide range of accommodation options, including simple B&Bs, characterful townhouses and fun, harbour-side spots. The best places to stay in Sag Harbor are intimate and quirky, providing the perfect base from which to enjoy Long Island.

The first official port in the USA, Sag Harbor was originally a whaling town, and its simple, narrow streets belie its historic importance. The town has top literary credentials, too: named in Herman Melville’s Moby Dick, it was also once the home of the writer John Steinbeck, and now offers cultural attractions aplenty. History buffs will be fascinated by the Whaling Museum, the Whaler’s Church and Umbrella House — the oldest house in town — where British troops stayed during the American Revolution. There are several fascinating cemeteries to explore, too, as well as the impressive Jermain Library.

Adventurers and nature lovers, on the other hand, will adore the wetlands and dunes surrounding Sag Harbor. Much of the area is protected as part of the Elizabeth A Morton National Wildlife Refuge, home to intriguing endangered species. The nearby woodlands, too, are home to deer, muskrat, red foxes, coyotes and woodchucks.

Back in town, stroll along the harbour, pop into cafés and vintage shops, and head to one of the town’s yacht clubs for the chance to get out on the water. Whether you’re into sailing, kayaking, fishing or spotting dolphins and harbour porpoises, there’s stacks for the whole family to try!

From water sports to historic buildings, Sag Harbor offers plenty for outdoorsy travellers and culture aficionados to experience. Many of the best places to stay in Sag Harbor are converted mansions, port-side cottages or former industrial buildings — one of our favourites is gorgeous restored townhouse. The top hotels fill up fast during the summer months, so book your stay well in advance!

The Best Places to Stay in Sag Harbor

For Foodies

• The American Hotel is a characterful townhouse featuring just eight antique-filled rooms. Lively and quirky, the property also boasts a fabulous restaurant with an award-winning wine list. Tuck into delectable French classics after big days out on the owner's 75-foot boat. Hip & happening; ideal for foodies.

For Families

• Baron's Cove is a boat club-style hotel overlooking the harbor. Perfect for active families, the property has a pool, access to an array of water sports, a buzzing kids' club and a great restaurant-bar. There's a soothing spa for the grown-ups to unwind in, too. Fun and laid-back, with luxurious rooms offering family-friendly options.

FOR A HOLIDAY Cottage

• If you'd prefer a self-catering option, we suggest that you visit our online partner Booking.com.

TRAVEL INFORMATION

• Fly to New York City and take a bus or taxi to Sag Harbor from there. The journey takes around 2 hours. Seasonal ferries also run from Block Island, London and Martha's Vineyard to nearby Montauk, just a short drive away.
• If you would like to hire a car, we suggest that you contact our online partner Rentalcars.
• For warm days, visit Sag Harbor between June and August when temperatures peak at around 26°C and there’s plenty to do outdoors. This is, however, the busiest time of year — time your trip for September or October for tranquility without the crowds. Sag Harbor is also a cosy winter destination.

Still not sure?

• See our list of the best places to stay in Montauk.
• Expand your search to include all the best places to stay in Long island or, explore our round-up of the 15 best hotels in The Hamptons.
• Widen the net even further to include our pick of the best hotels in New York State
• Or contact one of our friendly Gurus for advice.

Weather

Monthly Weather in Sag Harbor